they have a major lack of self esteem. it seems to be have been improving in recent years, but cleveland is a city that needs to be comfortable with themselves. this project regarding shrinking cities (this=my project) is an example of accepting the city, its tumultuous past and sometimes sad history and amplifying the interesting/exciting parts that currently exist.
Today was rough. I have spoken with my professors and classmates about problems that could come up because of my choosing a capstone site in an area close to my heart, the place i spent my high school years. Before today I was being careful not to assume my audience had any knowledge about the area or its issues, and I thought that would be the major issue with my personal connection to the site.
Well, I was wrong.
I went down a HUGE rabbit hole of aerial and historic images today. It started out all well and good, looking for images from the early 20th century in my site. It ended up being a really depressing trip though hundreds of images showcasing Cleveland's golden age and all the beautiful buildings (and full streets!) that existed from the 1900's to the 1950's. The planning that appears to have NEVER taken place after a certain point in history is infuriating. Now I am by no means an expert on all of Cleveland's history, but I just do not understand the thought process behind taking many of the cities main roads from what they were in 1948 to what they are now. All beautiful stone buildings, large residential houses and boulevard styling to bare parking lots and abandoned buildings.
My question is were those parking lots ever full? Where there ever years where the city needed the built environment it created?
UNFORTUNATELY, that is NOT my capstone question. UNFORTUNATELY X2, there only exist minimal aerial images and 2, TWO, images of areas of my site in the historic records I combed.
So back to the problems of loving the CLE, there was the issue of time; i spent 7 hours doing this with little real capstone project forward movement, and the issue of feelings; it was actually really rough and really really sad looking through all this stuff, I just want Cleveland to thrive. Is that too much to ask? (yes, Kammeron, it is, you have 5 months and you are one measly grad student)
Its been a month, and I have made some big strides towards my final capstone research question. I've almost picked a site! When I am in CLE next week for our Thanksgiving holiday, I have two goals: eat mashed potatoes and find a few block site in a neighborhood of Cleveland to use as my capstone canvas. Below you can read my most recent proposal "draft" (aka ramblings).
When I wrote this draft, I had just started to narrow down by site qualities, and at this point, I think i am almost set on choosing a neighborhood in Cleveland. I always made fun of my moms bumper sticker ("My heart's in Cleveland"), but I do understand the love of the CLE, and why not apply my knowledge earned over years of hard work to a place with such great potential?
Here goes nothin'
Elevator Pitch: Take a quarter square mile (or a specific urban fringe neighborhood) site that has been dramatically cleared because of foreclosures after shrinking populations and renew a sense of place and a sense of community on multiple scales. The site must be on an urban fringe, and will therefore be reconnected through design to an intact community via human interaction scale, landscape scale, and economic scale
Important Site Qualities:
suffering from a shrinking population because of a loss of industry or change in economic impacter to the city
on the fringe of a currently developed area with an intact community structure
exhibit an excess of open space because of abandoned building tear down
In the past few years foreclosures have rattled communities across the globe. Communities entire structures are changed by the shrinking of populations and changing of economic climates. Within shrinking communities homes and in extreme cases entire blocks can become abandoned. Abandonment of homes leads to a multitude of problems; fewer “eyes on the street,” built structures falling apart, dangerous untamed natural areas, community disconnection, fewer tax payers to support public works, schools and other amenities, and expensive infrastructure traveling out to areas that are no longer in need, etc. To limit the danger of decrepit buildings being left to rot, and possibly pose danger for people still residing in the neighborhoods affected, cities are spending billions of dollars to tear down foreclosed and abandoned homes. What is left are communities with an excess of open space and declining opportunities for human interaction.
This excess of open space that is created will be my capstone canvas. I will be taking a quarter square mile (or a specific urban fringe neighborhood) site that has been dramatically cleared because of foreclosures after shrinking populations and renew a sense of place and a sense of community on multiple scales. The site will be reconnected through design to an intact community via human interaction scale, landscape scale, and economic scale.
Research Questions:
How can landscape architecture work to renew a sense of community in a place that has been lost? How is that sense of community created? This question is one that has been a motivator for landscape architects for generations. Since the beginning of the profession a main goal has been using the landscape to create spaces people want to inhabit or inhabit in specific ways.
How can open space in debilitated communities be used to successfully create informal economies and a better quality of life for a neighborhoods inhabitants while also reconnecting said community to an existing formal economy and developed area.
The kinds of problem spaces I am tackling in my capstone will be an issue for years to come as population needs change and best-laid plans go to waste. Solutions on how to strengthen communities and creative ways to reconnect lost places into the common society grid will be necessary until all development is deemed “resilient.”
The research I have done up to this point has been narrowing my focus and creating a backdrop from which I will be able to design. Programming needs have become more apparent as I move through my research, but I have yet to arrive at a point where I feel comfortable physically designing on a site. I see myself choosing a site over the Thanksgiving break when I will have chances to explore possible site opportunities in Detroit, Cleveland, and Buffalo. Once the site is chosen, I look forward to being able to apply all of the research I have completed up to this point, and begin to understand all that was written in combination with the physicalities of the site.
Research Topics:
Program Goals:
Important Definitions
Foreclosure - a bank or other secured creditor selling or repossessing a parcel of real property (immovable property) after the owner has failed to comply with an agreement between the lender and borrower called a "mortgage" or "deed of trust."
Abandonment – something abandoned by its owner with the intention of not retaking it
Community - a social unit larger than a small village that shares common values
human interaction scale – the level of community at which people have day to day and human to human contact, interactions
landscape scale – a understand of the landscape that combines both the lands physical origins and the cultural overlay of human presence
economic scale – the level of community at which money is passed and humans make a livelihood
urban fringe - the transition zone where densely urban and suburban areas clash
excess open space – landscape parcels with no program and no necessary need at this point in time in a certain neighborhood